
The holiday card turns dangerous the day nobody may mention the fight in the car.
Most people use “kitsch” as a verdict on taste. The porcelain angel, the sunset with a Bible verse across it, the gift-shop painting of a child with enormous wet eyes: calling these kitsch means they are cheesy, and the worst they can do is embarrass the person who owns them. So it is strange that Milan Kundera, who watched Soviet tanks end the Prague Spring, put kitsch near the center of his account of political tyranny. Why would a novelist who lived under occupation worry about sentimental pictures?
The answer starts with what kitsch does to a feeling, and that is easiest to see in an ordinary object: the family photo on a holiday card. Everyone wears coordinated sweaters and smiles in front of the tree. The love in the picture may be entirely real. But the card offers itself as the truth of that family, and to do so it has pushed a great deal outside the frame: the argument in the car on the way to the studio, the bills, the sibling who resents the other one, the grandfather too ill to be photographed, the toddler’s diaper.
Kundera’s definition is deliberately crude. In The Unbearable Lightness of Being he calls kitsch the absolute denial of shit, in both the literal and the figurative sense: it excludes from view whatever is essentially unacceptable in human existence. Kitsch, on this account, is sentimentality with the dirty parts removed. The feeling is genuine. What is false is the implied claim that the feeling is the whole story.
The second tear
Kundera adds an element that explains why kitsch spreads instead of staying a private indulgence. Kitsch, he writes, makes two tears flow. The first says how nice it is to see children running on the grass. The second says how nice it is to be moved, together with all mankind, by children running on the grass, and it is the second tear that makes kitsch kitsch. The second tear is about the viewer and the company he is keeping.
That second tear is why kitsch is so hard to argue with. An objection to the holiday card sounds like an objection to the love in it. Anyone who points out what was cropped seems to be refusing to join everyone else who is moved, and so the objector, rather than the image, looks like the problem.
Now scale the card up to a state. Sabina, the painter in Kundera’s novel, grew up having to march in May Day parades, where the required expression was joy and the required gesture was unanimity. What she hated was less communism than its kitsch: the identical faces, the demand that everyone feel the same pure feeling at once. The holiday card asks you to admire a clean image; the parade requires you to inhabit one. Once the regime’s emotion has been purified, anyone who does not feel it reveals themselves as cynical, ungrateful, dead inside, and disbelief starts looking obscene. In the realm of totalitarian kitsch, Kundera wrote, all answers are given in advance.
This is why kitsch belongs beside totalitarianism rather than beside bad interior design. Ideology that only commands belief can be met by argument, because argument addresses the mind. Kitsch addresses the conscience. It says “feel this with us, or show that you are the kind of person who cannot feel properly,” and few people will risk that exposure for the sake of an observation about what the picture left out.
Kitsch is the beautiful lie that says: only this clean emotion is allowed; do not look behind the curtain.
What the lie protects
Why would anyone want such a lie, outside a regime that enforces it? Because kitsch keeps the viewer away from the parts of reality that would damage the image they hold of themselves and their group. The nationalist does not want to ask what his nation did to its poor; the humanitarian does not want the suffering person to become too complex, because complexity would interrupt the donor’s moral glow. The deleted material threatens the person looking more than the thing depicted, which is why the editing feels like loyalty from the inside. Cropping the car argument out of the holiday card does not feel like lying. It feels like protecting the family.
There is a serious counterweight. People need clean images. A family that put everything on its holiday card would be unbearable, and compressed symbols coordinate people precisely because they simplify. So the line cannot be “never simplify.” Sentiment becomes kitsch when it demands immunity from contradiction: when a useful simplification is promoted to the truth and defended against anyone who points at what it left out. Real patriotism can love a place while seeing its crimes; kitsch patriotism treats the seeing as betrayal.
So the mature response is audited sentiment rather than suspicion of feeling. You can send the holiday card. The test comes later, when someone in the family can look at it and laugh about the fight in the car, and the picture survives the memory instead of being defended against it. The opposite of kitsch is not ugliness but a beauty that survives the return of the mess.
References:
- Milan Kundera, The Unbearable Lightness of Being