
The old friend who no longer understands you may agree with you more than ever.
Most people know some version of this conversation. You meet a friend you were close to at twenty, after a decade spent in different cities and different kinds of work. The affection is intact. You still share the jokes, the names, and the references, and you probably agree on more than you did at twenty, since you have both read more and settled more of your views. Yet when you try to describe the thing that has mattered most to you this year, it lands flat. Your friend nods and says it makes sense, and you can tell that it does not.
The usual explanations are that one of you has stopped caring or that you need to communicate better. Venkatesh Rao’s essay “Can You Hear Me Now?” offers a third, less comfortable one, which he calls divergentism: growth tends to move people farther apart in thought-space even when the absolute number of shared beliefs increases. The shared region grows, but the unshared region grows faster. If that is right, the flat moment in the conversation is what growth ordinarily does to two people, and nobody has failed.
The convergentist bet
The opposite view is so natural that it rarely gets a name. Rao calls it convergentism: the bet that more shared beliefs should produce more agreement, intimacy, and mutual comprehension. It survives partly because the visible evidence favors it. Every successful conversation and shared joke looks like proof that people are moving closer. Evidence for divergence mostly takes the form of absences: stale conversations, the slow disappearance of topics that used to feel alive. Convergence leaves artifacts, and divergence leaves quiet. At the reunion, the jokes that still work are vivid, and the explanation that did not land is easy to file under a bad night.
Rao’s claim is that the quiet is the larger signal. The brutal version: growing people grow apart, not because they stop caring, but because lived experience compounds faster than mutual intelligibility.
Why the shared part shrinks
Communication can only use the shared part of experience, and most experience is not shareable in that sense. Call the rest private dark matter: embodied history, taste, half-formed intuitions, failures that cannot be compressed without lying. That material cannot be seen in conversation, but it still has mass. It bends judgment and changes what feels obvious or alive. So two people can hold the same explicit belief and mean different things by it, because the belief sits inside different private universes.
Growth makes the gap wider in a specific way. Each new distinction a person learns creates a new cost of explanation. Someone who has not paid that cost with you cannot simply receive the conclusion; they need the path, and the path may be years long. The friend at the reunion is hearing a conclusion without the decade that produced it. Shared vocabulary can increase while shared reality decreases.
What being heard was for
Rao’s sharpest move is connecting this to meaning. For the convergentist, a meaningful life is one whose value is recognized and answered back, so the cry for purpose often hides a more relational demand:
Can anyone hear the thing I am becoming?
That explains why silence can feel like nihilism even when nothing metaphysical has happened: the local social world has simply stopped returning usable signal. Human meaning has a dependency problem because much of what people call meaning depends on someone else staying available as witness and interpreter. When the friend nods without understanding, what hurts is less the misunderstanding than the hint that the most important part of your year may have no witness.
The divergentist keeps value and drops the requirement that it be socially validated to exist. A coconut on a deserted island can be good even if nobody applauds your enjoyment of it. That is what lets a person keep growing without treating every failure of recognition as a verdict on the growth.
None of this means intimacy is fake. It means intimacy requires ongoing translation labor, because there is no final shared map that removes the need to keep listening. A healthy relationship is one where divergence remains speakable, and trust is what makes it speakable: confidence that future misunderstandings can survive translation, so a difference can be explored instead of read as abandonment.
That changes what the flat moment at the reunion means. The wounded convergentist hears every flat answer as rejection and every silence as meaninglessness. The divergentist learns that being heard is local, temporary, costly, and precious. If you give your friend more of the path (the year behind the conclusion, the failures that made it matter) and they actually hear you, that is not proof that convergence has won. It is a rare event, produced by attention, timing, and grace. If they still cannot follow, not every silence is a verdict. Some distance simply means the universe kept expanding.
References:
- Venkatesh Rao, Can You Hear Me Now?, Ribbonfarm