
Every inflated grade is a hard conversation some adult decided not to have.
A ninth-grader finishes Algebra I with a B. She can’t solve a linear equation without a worked example beside her, and her teacher knows it. But a C would have meant an email from her parents, a dent in the school’s pass rate, and perhaps a student who stops trying. The B costs nothing anyone can see. She feels encouraged, her parents feel reassured, the school’s numbers look healthier, and the teacher gets a quiet afternoon.
Almost everyone in that story was trying to be kind. So who was the B kind to? Follow her into geometry and the answer gets uncomfortable. The algebra she didn’t learn doesn’t disappear. It moves into geometry, chemistry, statistics, college placement, choice of major and her sense of what she is capable of, arriving at each stage with a larger bill. That is why grade inflation is better described as compassionate fraud: a counterfeit signal issued in the emotional register of kindness.
Inflated grades are not generous; they are deferred failure with adult fingerprints removed.
What a grade is for
A grade isn’t the purpose of school. It is a feedback signal about the distance between what a student can do and what the next stage will require. Her B was supposed to tell her what she can’t yet do, tell her teacher where instruction failed, tell her parents whether reassurance is warranted, and tell the geometry teacher what he can assume. Inflation corrupts all of those at once.
The corruption persists because the grade has become a target. It began as a measure of learning, and then college admissions, teacher evaluations, graduation rates, district dashboards and student self-esteem all came to depend on it. Once that happens, as Goodhart’s Law predicts, the system optimizes the grade directly and learning becomes the inconvenient middleman. Nobody inside notices, because the dashboard improves: more A’s, fewer failures, higher graduation, less visible disparity. The numbers say the system is getting kinder and more effective. The student simply knows less than the transcript says.
What the evidence shows
The inflation is well documented at the top. Harvard’s faculty discussion in 2023 reported that 79 percent of Harvard College grades in 2020-21 were A-range, up from 60 percent a decade earlier, with mean grades rising from 3.41 in 2002-03 to 3.80 in 2020-21. A 2023 Yale report found about 79 percent of grades in 2022-23 were A or A-minus, up from just over 67 percent in 2010-11. Harvard’s deeper worry was compression: when almost everyone sits near the ceiling, the grade stops carrying information, and students route distinction into “shadow systems” like recommendations and extracurriculars.
The best recent evidence on harm comes from Denning, Nesbit, Pope and Warnick’s 2026 paper, Easy A’s, Less Pay, which links high school records from Los Angeles and Maryland to college and earnings data. Its key move is to separate two kinds of leniency. Passing grade inflation makes it easier for a student near failure to pass. Mean grade inflation lifts grades across the whole distribution.
The two behave differently. Passing leniency can reduce grade retention and modestly raise high-school graduation for students near the edge: a D instead of an F can keep a marginal student inside the institutional path long enough to recover, so mercy at the cliff can be real. Mean inflation, the kind our algebra student received, does the opposite. Students assigned to teachers who inflate grades across the board later have lower test scores, lower high-school graduation, lower college enrollment and lower earnings. The authors estimate that one standard deviation more mean grade inflation reduces the present discounted value of lifetime earnings for that teacher’s students by roughly $213,872 per year of teaching.
Effort is one plausible channel. Philip Babcock found that students study substantially less when the expected grade is high, and Babcock and Mindy Marks documented the time full-time college students spent on class and study falling from around 40 hours a week in 1961 to about 27 in 2003. Inflation is not the only cause, but it fits the incentive: when the system lowers the price of an A, students rationally buy less learning.
None of this means strict grading is good. Some strict graders are lazy, punitive or simply bad teachers. The conclusion is narrower and stronger: when grades are inflated beyond demonstrated competence, students lose the feedback that would have let them adapt before reality became expensive.
Who pays
The first loss is calibration. Our student needs to know not just whether she is improving but where she stands, and the B tells her she is ready for geometry when she isn’t. A low grade in ninth grade is a painful signal while the stakes are still local. A failed college course, a lost scholarship or a derailed major is the same signal after compounding. Inflation doesn’t eliminate failure. It moves failure from a recoverable stage to one that may not be.
The second loss falls hardest on the students inflation is often meant to protect. Suppose a classmate gets the same B and actually knows the algebra. Their transcripts are equal and their futures are not. If her family can afford a tutor, someone may notice the gap and pay to close it. If they can’t, she has only the inflated signal and no hidden repair system behind it. Inflation removes the public signal that would have justified intervention and leaves the private signals that well-resourced families already know how to read. Selective institutions, meanwhile, don’t stop selecting when grades compress. They select through letters, research access, internships and parent networks, which are subtler, more socially inherited and harder for outsiders to contest.
And when she finally meets the next level of reality, it feels like betrayal rather than feedback. “If I was a B student, why am I drowning?” The honest answer is humiliating: the grade wasn’t telling the truth.
Why the adults keep doing it
The people who inflate grades are mostly not cynical. They want to prevent humiliation, reduce anxiety, close gaps and protect children from a brutal status machine, and those motives are real. But compassion without standards becomes adult self-soothing. The teacher avoids the student’s pain, the administrator avoids the parent complaint, the district avoids ugly disparities, the professor avoids bad course evaluations, and the reformer avoids the accusation that their institutions reproduce inequality. Everyone avoids the moment of saying, “You are not there yet.”
That is the absence of adults in grading form. An adult is someone who can bear being disliked while telling the truth in a form the child can use. Status makes this harder. In elite education debates, whoever defends standards can be made to look cruel, old-fashioned or complicit in inequality, while whoever relaxes them looks humane and sophisticated. Once that prestige gradient forms, honesty becomes reputationally expensive.
Underneath is a failure to distinguish pain that damages from pain that informs. An arbitrary, humiliating grade damages. A truthful low grade, paired with support and a path forward, informs. Collapsing both into “harm” removes the instrument panel from the cockpit and calls it kindness. The Denning paper draws the line in roughly the right place: leniency that keeps a student from falling off the cliff preserves her contact with reality, while leniency that tells everyone they are fine severs it.
The phrase that holds standards and mercy together is “not yet.” It keeps the standard and the student’s future at once: you aren’t there, the road remains, and your dignity doesn’t depend on pretending otherwise. Our ninth-grader needed someone to say it in algebra, while it was still cheap. The harder question is who in her school would have been rewarded for saying it.
References:
- Jeffrey T. Denning, Rachel L. Nesbit, Nolan G. Pope, and Merrill Warnick, Easy A’s, Less Pay: The Long-Term Effects of Grade Inflation, 2026
- Rahem D. Hamid and Elias J. Schisgall, Harvard Report Shows 79% A-Range Grades Awarded in 2020-21, The Harvard Crimson, 2023
- Susan H. Greenberg, Yale Report Shows Grade Inflation Is Real, Inside Higher Ed, 2023
- Evangeleen Pattison, Eric Grodsky, and Chandra Muller, Is the Sky Falling? Grade Inflation and the Signaling Power of Grades, Educational Researcher, 2013
- Philip S. Babcock and Mindy Marks, The Falling Time Cost of College, NBER, 2010
- David Griffith and Adam Tyner, “Equitable” Grading Through the Eyes of Teachers, Thomas B. Fordham Institute, 2025
- Greta Reich, California math matters: Stanford looks into complaints on professor Jo Boaler, The Stanford Daily, 2024
- Greta Reich, Stanford closes review into complaint on Jo Boaler, The Stanford Daily, 2024