Being the smart kid lasts exactly until you move to a school full of them.

Back in the U.S., I was a dorky geek. Almost no social life, few friends, but perfect grades. Gifted and Talented classes. SATs four years early. I was well on my way to becoming an introverted scholar-guy receiving an above-average salary for some technical job most people would find boring. I could justify my lack of social grace with “intelligence.”

Then I moved to China for school, and everyone had the exact same personality as me.

If the trait that defines you turns out to be ordinary somewhere else, was it ever really you?

The slap

At Yan An Middle School, one of the top schools in Shanghai, I was surrounded by people who were better at the thing I had built my entire identity around. The distinguishing trait that had made me special in the U.S. was the baseline in China. My self-esteem and my sense of self took the same hit simultaneously, because they were the same thing.

I tried to reclaim some “former glory,” to be who I “was,” and eventually got tired of it. Everyone around me was optimizing for the same exam, and most were better at it than me. The choice was to keep competing on a track where I was average, or to start asking who I could be rather than who I had been.

What got stripped away

With everything I had based my sense of self on taken away, I was forced to rediscover who I really am. First I saw that grades are shallow, which I had never seen while grades were the currency I was rich in. Then something deeper: despite my prior success in science and mathematics, I had never been intrinsically interested in these subjects. I had succeeded for the status that success in these fields brought me. The motivation was neediness wearing the costume of intellectual passion.

Out of the cave

I was forcibly taken from Plato’s cave and thrust into the light, eyes burning, seeing a reality I did not want. Yet this truth is liberating, because it showed what the old identity had been. The comfortable version of me (smart kid, good grades, heading for a respectable career) was a Locally Optimal strategy. It worked in the environment that shaped it, and transplanting it into a different culture revealed that it was environment-dependent, not identity-deep. The “intelligence” that felt like my core was a reference-point artifact: I was special only relative to the sample I happened to grow up in.

In the language of cats and dogs, my identity was entirely dog-constructed, built by looking at other people and finding myself above them. When the sample changed, the identity collapsed, which is precisely the moment a cat-identity can begin.

Can begin, not will. University at Fudan did not fix this. Youth is quickly deceived only because it is quick to hope, and the temple of knowledge I had imagined turned out to be more of the same single-mindedness, pointed in a different direction. Displacement removes the old identity, but it does not hand you a new one, and the easiest replacement is another set of visible markers.

Sometimes I wonder where I would be if I had stayed in the U.S. But it was in China that I realized how fragile an identity built on external metrics really is, and there that the question shifted from “what am I good at?” to “who am I when I am not good at anything?”

That question has no comfortable answer. But it feels more right than the old one.

References: