
The draft you never send can never be rejected.
A graduate student has a chapter that has been “almost done” for eight months. She knows the delay is hurting her. Her advisor is losing patience, the funding clock is running, and every week of not finishing feels worse than finishing badly would. She has read the productivity books. So why does she keep not sending it?
The usual answer treats the delay as a malfunction: a missing habit, weak discipline, a broken reward system. Fix the part and the behavior goes away. But look at what the delay is actually doing. Procrastination is not the absence of work. It is a self-punishing form of work, because guilt and avoidance take effort too. And it makes sense once you see how exposed she feels to criticism and to her own perfectionism. If her judgment of the chapter and her sense of her own worth have fused, then not finishing is the only safe move, because a chapter that is never submitted can never be found wanting.
That is the claim of Chris Lakin’s idea of the locally optimal strategy. The behaviors that look most dysfunctional from outside are often solving a real problem from inside. Self-loathing avoids conflict by agreeing in advance with the harshest possible judgment. Emotional numbness avoids overwhelming pain by shutting the channel down. Each is a configuration the nervous system settled into because it worked well enough in the environment that shaped it.
Stuck on a small hill
Picture yourself on a small hill in fog. It is not the tallest hill in the landscape, but every step you can take from where you stand goes downward. So you stay, because every move feels like getting worse. Nothing on the hill can tell you a taller one exists, and reaching it means accepting a descent first.
The student is on that hill. Sending the chapter means a few weeks of exposure: comments, revisions, the chance that it isn’t good enough. Holding it keeps her safe from all of that, at the price of a slow, diffuse cost that never arrives on any particular day. From where she stands, finishing feels like the wrong direction.
Three things keep her there.
The strategy actually works. For its narrow purpose, the delay delivers: she really has avoided being judged. Self-loathing really does reduce conflict, and numbness really does block pain. The system has evidence that its solution is functional, and that evidence is what makes it stable.
Leaving requires getting worse first. The way off the small hill goes down. For a nervous system tuned to avoid pain, “temporarily worse” feels the same as “wrong direction”, so every attempt to change gets read as a mistake and corrected back.
The purpose is unconscious. You cannot negotiate with a strategy you don’t know you are running. The student does not experience her delay as protection. She experiences it as laziness, which is why her attempts to fix it with willpower keep failing.
That last point turns the usual advice around. Only once you fully understand what an issue is doing for you does a step change toward resolving it become possible. Attack the symptom without knowing its function and the system defends itself: remove the delay by force, with a hard deadline or an accountability partner, and the underlying need is still there, so the system rebuilds the old pattern or substitutes a worse one. Gerald Weinberg makes a similar point in Are Your Lights On?: fewer people want their problems solved than you would think, because the problem gives structure. It explains why things are bad, justifies how you live, and gives you a story about yourself.
The body runs the same loop
The pattern is not only psychological. Chronic tension can follow the same logic. A feeling starts to surface, some part of the system predicts that noticing it would be dangerous, and the muscles brace around it to keep it down. Suppression makes the feeling push harder, so the bracing tightens to match. Both sides are doing their jobs, and the result is pain with no obvious physical cause, because the cause is the system fighting itself.
focusing is one way to work with this directly: you ask the body what a tension or behavior is doing for you and wait for the felt sense to answer. Internal Family Systems arrives at the same place with different vocabulary. In No Bad Parts, every locally optimal strategy is a protector, a part that solved a real problem once, is frozen in that moment, and will fight harder if attacked. The student’s delay is a protector guarding her against the verdict she fears. It has to be heard before the fear it guards can be met.
Where the reframe goes wrong
The obvious danger is that “it’s protecting you” becomes a reason never to change. Understanding a strategy’s function is meant to give leverage, not to excuse it. The garden’s note on therapeutic etiology makes the limit precise: trace a strategy to its protective function and you have reached the depth where you can choose differently. Dig past that, into ever-finer accounts of where the pattern came from, and the diagnosis itself becomes the new small hill, a comfortable place to stand that explains everything and requires nothing.
So the reframe is not that dysfunction is secretly fine. It is that growth looks less like fixing a broken part and more like finding something that works better than the old solution. That is also why growth so often feels like loss before it feels like gain. The student is not adding a skill when she sends the chapter. She is giving up a strategy that has kept her safe, before she has any proof that what replaces it will hold. Safety, insight and new experience widen the search so a higher hill can come into view. Whether she will take the first step down without that proof is the part no reframe can do for her.
References:
- Locally Optimal — Chris Lakin